dine
Calusa Restaurant at Baker's Cay Resort
Calusa invites guests to experience the flavor and spirit of the Keys from a beautiful waterfront setting above Florida Bay. Located at Baker’s Cay Resort, the restaurant blends contemporary American cuisine with coastal and Caribbean influences, showcasing fresh, locally sourced seafood, vibrant seasonal ingredients, and a warm, modern island aesthetic. Mornings open with a bright, coastal-inspired breakfast, with guests choosing from a plentiful breakfast buffet or à la carte favorites served with a sweeping sunrise skyline. As the day unfolds, handcrafted cocktails, refined dishes, and unforgettable sunsets create an atmosphere that feels both relaxed and sophisticated, making Calusa a destination for anyone seeking the essence of waterfront dining in the Keys.
Sunset Dining
Some of the best evenings in Key Largo begin with a sunset. Settle in at Calusa for sweeping water views as the sky changes over the water, paired with handcrafted cocktails and elevated American cuisine.
Whether you’re staying at Baker’s Cay or joining us from the neighborhood, come for dinner, stay for the sunset, and experience waterfront dining at its best.
Menus
Use end key, home key, or arrow keys to navigate between tabs
*There is risk associated with consuming raw oysters. If you have chronic illness of the liver, stomach or blood or have immune disorders, you are at greater risk of serious illness from raw oysters, and should eat oysters fully cooked. If unsure of your risk, consult a physician. Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfi sh, or eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illness especially if you have certain medical conditions
Shared
Pistachio Pesto Hummus
$ 18.00
gherkins, olives, roasted peppers, sesame flatbread, nann bread (GF)
Brussel Sprouts Con Tartufo
$ 19.00
bacon lardons, fried egg, summer truffle, shaved reggiano (GF)
Lamb Chops
$ 24.00
roasted maitake mushroom, sweet onion agrodolce, chives oil (GF)
Grilled Octopus
$ 27.00
smoked baby gold potato salad, bacon lardon, honey glaze, citrus remoulade (GF)
Fritto Mistol Di Mare
$ 23.00
crispy calamari & vegetables san marzano tomato sauce, chili lime glaze, cilantro, garlic aioli
Tiger Prawns
$ 23.00
sweet chili sauce, watermelon, cucumber, jalapeño, aleppo pepper flakes (GF)
STEAM MUSSEL
$ 20.00
lemongrass coconut curry broth, ginger root, symbol oelek chili, cilantro grilled bread
Raw Bar
Oysters*
(6)
$ 24.00
(12)
$ 48.00
chef's selection of seasonal oysters
Ahi Poke*
$ 28.00
lump blue crab, tuna, masago, avocado, mango, cucumber, unagi sauce, spicy mayo, sesame wonton chips
Tiger Jumbo Shrimp Cocktail
$ 28.00
tiger prawns, cucumber salad, mustard aioli, cocktail sauce (GF)
Calusa Tower*
Half
$ 60.00
Full
$ 120.00
1 doz. oyster, 8 tiger prawns, tuna tartare, jumbo lump blue crab salad, poached lobster tail, cocktail sauce, mignonette, mustard aioli
From the Garden
Prosciutto and Burrata
$ 21.00
arugula, cantaloupe, confit cherry tomatoes, citrus olive oil (GF)
Roasted Roots
$ 19.00
beetroot, carrot, frisee lettuce, point reyes blue cheese, honey glaze, evo (GF)
Tuscan Caesar
$ 19.00
baby gem lettuce, sundried tomato pesto, shaved parmesan, herbed breadcrumbs
Mediterranean Wedge
$ 20.00
baby iceberg, za'atar spiced bacon, hard boiled egg, artichoke, feta cheese, olives, tomato pickled red onion, green goddess dressing
From the Dock
Grilled Florida Mahi
$ 38.00
lemon garlic potatoes, broccolini, island salsa, curry coconut sauce (GF)
Yellowtail Snapper
$ 40.00
sweet potato and corn hash, coconut rice, island salsa (GF)
Roasted Grouper
$ 46.00
wild mushrooms, asparagus, classic bearnaise (GF)
Whole Fish
$ 48.00
fried local fish, caribbean rice and peas, sweet plantains, escovitch sauce
Hook and Cook
(per person)
$ 40.00
Catch a whopper? Clean it, filet it and let us prepare! Preparation Choice: blackened, fried, grilled, baked choice of two sides Gluten free on request
Steaks
choice of finishing sauce, red wine demi-glace or chimichurri
10oz Prime New York
$ 60.00
(GF)
12oz Prime Ribeye
$ 70.00
(GF)
8oz Prime Filet Mignon
$ 80.00
(GF)
Add a Lobster Tail
$ 39.00
(GF)
From the Land
Roasted Chicken
$ 36.00
charred greens and roasted cipollini onion, pink peppercorn, salsa verde (GF)
Braised Short Rib
$ 44.00
yukon mashed potato, garlic spinach, bordelaise (GF)
Pasta
Pappardelle
$ 48.00
gulf shrimp, lobster, middleneck clams, p.e.i mussels, garlic, white wine cream sauce gluten free on request
Campanelle
$ 30.00
wild mushroom, roasted tomato and pepper, shallot, english green pea, basil pesto
Gnocchi
$ 36.00
oxtail ragu, bordelaise, roasted cipollini onion, english peas, gremolata
Sides
$9 each
Garlic Spinach
(GF)
Lemon Garlic Potatoes
(GF)
Yukon Gold Mashed Potatoes
(GF)
Wild Forest Mushrooms
(GF)
Grilled Broccolini
(GF)
Roasted Asparagus
(GF)
Coconut Jasime Rice
(GF)
Caribbean Rice and Peas
(GF)
Sweet Potato Pure
(GF)
Sweets
Award-Winning Key Lime Pie
$ 12.00
graham cracker crust, guava glaze, lime zest
White Chocolate Bread Pudding
$ 12.00
baileys rum, creme anglaise
Chocolate Torte
$ 12.00
ganache, salted caramel
Crafted Cocktails
sip, savor & enjoy the sunset; add smoke ($1 per drink): apple, cherry, hickory or mesquite
Cucumber Cooler
$ 16.00
hendrick's gin, st. germain, cucumber, lemon juice, ginger ale
Hemingway's Veranda
$ 15.00
cruzan aged light rum, luxardo, grapefruit juice, lime juice
Guava Gimlet
$ 16.00
amsterdam vodka, guava liqueur, lime juice
Smoked Old Fashioned
$ 17.00
jim beam kentucky straight bourbon whiskey, simple syrup, angostura bitters, orange bitters
Spicy Passion
$ 17.00
cazadores blanco tequila, passion fruit, jalapeño, lime, agave
Sunset Sound
$ 15.00
aperol, ketel one grapefruit & rose botanical vodka, lemon juice, simple
Vesper Martini
$ 16.00
amsterdam vodka & gin, lillet
Wine
Champagne & Sparkling
Comte De Chamberi, Spain
$ 12.00
$ 60.00
La Marca Prosecco, Italy
$ 15.00
$ 75.00
Moët & Chandon Brut Impérial Split, France
$ 60.00
187ml
Moët & Chandon Brut Impérial, France
$ 280.00
Veuve Clicquot Brut, France
$ 280.00
Dom Pérignon Brut 2015, France
$ 900.00
Rosé
Miraval, Côtes De Provence
$ 17.00
$ 60.00
Whispering Angel, Côtes De Provence
$ 18.00
$ 90.00
Sauvignon Blanc
Dashwood, Marlborough
$ 17.00
$ 85.00
Whitehaven, New Zealand
$ 16.00
$ 80.00
Duckhorn, North Coast
$ 19.00
$ 95.00
Pinot Grigio
Maso Canali, Italy
$ 15.00
$ 75.00
Chardonnay
Bravium, Russian River Valley
$ 15.00
$ 75.00
Starmont, California
$ 17.00
$ 85.00
Interesting Whites
Stude, Pinot Gris, California
$ 17.00
$ 85.00
Loimer Langenloiser, Riesling, Germany
$ 15.00
$ 75.00
Fournier Sancerre, "Les Belles Vignes," France
$ 19.00
$ 95.00
Pinot Noir
Sea Sun By Caymus
$ 15.00
$ 75.00
Fiddlestix By Stude
$ 18.00
$ 90.00
Cabernet Sauvignon
Caymus Vinyards "Bonanza" California
$ 15.00
$ 75.00
Daou, California
$ 19.00
$ 95.00
Intrinsic, Columbia Valley, Washington
$ 16.00
$ 80.00
Merlot
St Francis, Sonoma, California
$ 16.00
$ 80.00
Interesting Reds
Unshackled By The Prisoner Red Blend
$ 16.00
$ 80.00
Querceto Chianti Classico Riserva 2020, Italy
$ 17.00
$ 85.00
Chevalier De Lascombes Margaux 2022, France
$ 19.00
$ 95.00
Main
Organic Steel-Cut Oatmeal
$ 10.00
dried fruit, brown sugar, coconut, honey, cinnamon (GF)
Island Avocado Toast
$ 24.00
poached egg, avocado, arugula, roasted baby tomato, pickled red onion, grilled sourdough
Classic Stack of Pancakes
$ 18.00
whipped butter, fresh berries, warm maple syrup
Baker's Cay Eggs
$ 16.00
three cage free eggs your style
Ben's Benedict
$ 18.00
poached eggs, Canadian bacon on a English muffin, hollandaise sauce, breakfast potatoes
Breakfast Buffet
Breakfast Buffet
$ 39.00
Children Under 12
$ 19.00
Includes: Coffee, Tea and Orange juice
Make Your Own Omelet
Make Your Own Omelet
$ 19.00
three cage-free eggs, breakfast potatoes; choice of three toppings: mushroom, peppers, spinach, onion, cheddar cheese, feta cheese, bacon, sausage
Fresh Juice
$14. Prepared in-house daily
Green Garden
green apple, spinach, kale, cucumber, celery, lemon
Beet - Root - Fruit
beet, carrot, celery, apple, ginger
Carrot Refresh
carrot, orange, pineapple, ginger, turmeric
$15
Main
Chicken Tenders
served with choice of fries, fresh fruit or rice
Macaroni and Cheese
served with chef's vegetable
Hamburger
choice of cheese, served with choice of fries, fresh fruit or rice
Grilled Keys Shrimp & Rice
Fresh Fish
served with choice of fries, fresh fruit or rice and chef's vegetable
Key Lime Banana Split
vanilla ice cream, cherries and key lime sprinkles
Champagne & Sparkling
Sweet
Veuve Clicquot Demi Sec Champagne FRA
$ 140.00
Dry—Listed from Milder to Stronger
Jeio Brut Prosecco ITA
$ 12.00
$ 45.00
Pink Flamingo Rosé FRA
$ 10.00
$ 40.00
Campo Viejo Brut Rosé Cava ESP
$ 12.00
$ 45.00
Moët & Chandon Brut Rosé Champagne "Impérial" FRA
$ 120.00
Pommery Brut Champagne "Royal" FRA
$ 120.00
Perrier Jouët Brut Champagne "Belle Epoque" FRA
$ 205.00
Moët & Chandon Brut Champagne "Impérial" FRA
$ 103.00
Veuve Clicquot Brut Champagne "Yellow Label" FRA
$ 130.00
G.H. Mumm Brut Champagne "Grand Cordon" FRA
$ 120.00
Dom Pérignon Brut Champagne FRA
$ 255.00
Rosé
Listed from milder to stronger
Pink Flamingo Gris Rosé Sable de Camargue FRA
$ 45.00
Crios Malbec Rosé Mendoza ARG
$ 12.00
$ 45.00
Sauvignon Blanc
Listed from milder to stronger
Saint Claire Family Estate Marlborough NZL
$ 70.00
Crowded House Sauvignon Blanc Marlborough NZL
$ 48.00
FerrariCarano Sauvignon Blanc "Fumé Blanc" Sonoma CA
$ 12.00
$ 45.00
Long Meadow Ranch Sauvignon Blanc Rutherford
$ 15.00
$ 55.00
La Perrière Sancerre FRA
$ 18.00
$ 60.00
Chalk Hill Sauvignon Blanc Chalk Hill CA
$ 13.00
$ 56.00
Pinot Grigio & Pinot Gris
Listed from milder to stronger
Tolloy Pinot Grigio Südtirol ITA
$ 14.00
$ 52.00
Art of the Cooper Pinot Grigio Monterey CA
$ 48.00
Lunardi Pinot Grigio Venezie ITA
$ 12.00
$ 45.00
Livio Felluga Pinot Grigio Colli Orientali ITA
$ 52.00
Lange Pinot Gris Willamette OR
$ 48.00
Chardonnay
Listed from Milder to Stronger
Louis Jadot Pouilly Fuissé FRA
$ 58.00
Starmont Chardonnay Carneros CA
$ 15.00
$ 55.00
Diora Chardonnay "La Splendeur du Soleil" Monterey CA
$ 48.00
Louis Latour Puligny Montrachet 1er Cru FRA
$ 210.00
Full Intensity
Chalk Hill Chardonnay Chalk Hill CA
$ 20.00
$ 60.00
Newton Chardonnay "Unfiltered" Napa CA
$ 78.00
Far Niente Chardonnay Napa CA
$ 25.00
$ 90.00
Interesting Whites
Sweet Sparkling
Bottega Moscato Spumante "Petalo" ITA
$ 40.00
Sweet and Off Dry | Sweetest to Less Sweet
August Kesseler Riesling Kabinett "R" Rheingau DEU
$ 15.00
$ 55.00
Charles Smith Riesling "Kung Fu Girl" WA
$ 12.00
$ 45.00
Friedrich Wilhelm Riesling Feinherb "Fritz Willi" Mosel DEU
$ 15.00
$ 55.00
Light Intensity
Quinta de Azevedo Vinho Verde "Single Estate" PRT
$ 40.00
Pazo Señorans Albariño Rías Baixas ESP
$ 48.00
Simonnet Febvre Chablis FRA
$ 14.00
$ 56.00
Medium Intensity
Antinori Vermentino "Guado al Tasso" Bolgheri ITA
$ 48.00
Pinot Noir
Listed from milder to stronger
Light Intensity
Sea Sun Pinot Noir CA
$ 15.00
$ 55.00
WVV Pinot Noir "Whole Cluster" Willamette OR
$ 52.00
Louis Latour Santenay FRA
$ 60.00
Emeritus "Estate" Russian River CA
$ 91.00
Landmark Pinot Noir "Overlook" CA
$ 15.00
$ 55.00
Medium Intensity
Goldeneye Pinot Noir Anderson CA
$ 32.00
$ 100.00
Kenwood "Six Ridges" Russian River CA
$ 18.00
$ 60.00
Merlot
Listed from milder to stronger
St. Francis Merlot Sonoma CA
$ 15.00
$ 55.00
Oberon Merlot Napa CA
$ 13.00
$ 52.00
Duckhorn Merlot Napa CA
$ 32.00
$ 100.00
Cabernet Sauvignon
Listed from milder to stronger
Medium Intensity
Buena Vista Cabernet North Coast CA
$ 14.00
$ 52.00
BV Cabernet Napa CA
$ 60.00
Substance Cabernet "Cs" WA
$ 15.00
$ 55.00
Intrinsic Cabernet WA
$ 14.00
$ 52.00
Full Intensity
Honig Cabernet Napa CA
$ 91.00
Greenwing Cabernet WA
$ 18.00
$ 60.00
Jordan Cabernet Alexander CA
$ 130.00
Hess Collection Cabernet Mount Veeder CA
$ 40.00
$ 110.00
Opus One Napa CA
$ 420.00
Interesting Reds
Listed from Milder to Stronger
Palacios Remondo Rioja "La Vendimia" ESP
$ 12.00
$ 45.00
Medium Intensity
Antinori Chianti Classico "Marchese Antinori" Riserva ITA
$ 30.00
$ 95.00
Gabbiano Chianti Classico "Cavaliere d'Oro" Riserva ITA
$ 48.00
Maison Les Alexandrins Syrah Vin de FRA
$ 12.00
$ 45.00
Barossa Valley GSM Barossa AUS
$ 45.00
The Prisoner Red "Unshackled" CA
$ 18.00
$ 60.00
If You See Kay Red Paso Robles CA
$ 15.00
$ 55.00
Terrazas Malbec "High Altitude" Mendoza Reserva ARG
$ 14.00
$ 52.00
Lafite Médoc "Légende" FRA
$ 15.00
$ 55.00
Full Intensity
Artezin Zinfandel "Old Vine" Mendocino CA
$ 14.00
$ 52.00
Achaval Ferrer Malbec Mendoza ARG
$ 52.00
Dry Creek Vineyard Zinfandel "Old Vine" CA
$ 18.00
$ 62.00
Penfolds Shiraz "Max's" S. AUS
$ 48.00
Opaque Petit Verdot Paso Robles CA
$ 18.00
$ 60.00
Numanthia Toro "Termes" ESP
$ 74.00
Penfolds Cabernet/Shiraz "Bin 389" S. AUS
$ 140.00
Meritage "The Mariner" Dry Creek CA
$ 22.00
$ 78.00
Chalk Hill Red "Estate" Chalk Hill CA
$ 30.00
$ 95.00
Cocktails
Cuba Especiale
$ 16.00
Papa's Pilar Dark Rum, Lime Juice, Falernum, Angostura, Bitters, Mexican Coca Cola
Whiskey Smash
$ 16.00
Bulleit Bourbon, Mint, Lemon, Simple Syrup
Black Molasses Old Fashioned
$ 16.00
Redemption Rye, Bacardi Black, Molasses, Simple Syrup, Angostura Bitters, Orange. Add Smoke: Apple, Cherry, Hickory, and Mesquite
Calavera Cobbler
$ 16.00
Tequila Ocho Añejo, Grand Marnier, Red Wine, Lemon, Orange, Berries and Mint
Sparkling Coconut Water
$ 16.00
Drakes Vodka, Coconut Water, Lemon, Honey, Prosecco, Garnished with Cinnamon and Orange
Cucumber Cooler
$ 16.00
Hendricks Gin, St. Germaine, Lemon Juice, Ginger Ale
Dock to Dish
Uniquely sustainable cuisine. One of the first seafood initiatives of its kind, Dock to Dish™ connects guests with small-scale anglers to catch and prepare a high-quality, hyper-local sunset dinner experience.
Other restaurants you may like
-
Tiki BarIsland time all the time. Retro-inspired fun abounds at Tiki Bar with a collection of refreshing fruit-infused frozen concoctions, beachside food service, and ice-cold domestic and imported brews.
-
The Pool Bar
Surrounded by nature, plunged into relaxation. A hidden respite, The Pool Bar elevates poolside lounging with a fresh selection of signature cocktails and summer-inspired, apres-swim fare from our food truck.
-
Dry Rocks
Inspired by the laidback indulgence of the Keys, Dry Rocks offers casual dining day and night with Mexican fare, custom barreled Patron tequila, live music, and a perfectly crafted beachfront experience.
-
Dock to Dish
Uniquely sustainable cuisine. One of the first seafood initiatives of its kind, Dock to Dish™ connects guests with small-scale anglers to catch and prepare a high-quality, hyper-local sunset dinner experience.
your stories
#atthecay
